I had to think on this one a while. I'm like Jim, we've found several items we love. OLD MONEY tops the list. Someone left a 1904 Indian head penny in one of our favorite Smoky Mt. Caches (mr. winners garden of love). And all those Sacagawea dollars we've been finding are pretty cool (thanks to who ever left those

)
But I love my JJC keychain

Jim got him one out of a recent cache, we keep watch on everyones keys, to see if we notice another cacher

LOL...
And also, my very first FTF, was Braff and Mandarue's now archived 'Grand View' of a drive in (which should be revived for the event, IMHO, maybe a 'grand' place for a CITO event ....)I recieved a FTF ribbon, I still keep it in my glove box in my car, maybe I'll scrapbook it someday!
Another favorite that comes to mind that we recieved out of Spongebob's Mail Pouch barn. It didn't have a TB tag, BUT was a traveler of sorts, it was a key chain made by a troop of cub scouts in PA, they made so many of the key chains, and were placed in a cache in PA. They were hand beaded with numbers in the design (with glow in the dark beads I might add which was pretty darn cool). You had to email the troop leader with the keychains number, and where/ what cache you dropped it off in the troops kept up with the keychains travel that way. I have no ideal where mine is now, the cache was archived

...
Thanks for taking me back to think on my geo-caching adventures!
Kim...